The Contrarian

“In the investment markets, what everyone knows is usually not worth knowing.”

Are Cryptocurrency Offerings Like Bitcoin Illegal?

China has prohibited them. Other countries are considering similar moves. There are now over 300 crypto-currencies. Billions of dollars have flowed in. Observers say that many of the offerings are scams. But who cares if you might double your money in a month.

Here is an article about the SEC and why all these offerings may be illegal, and that all these celebrities might be breaking the law.

In July, the SEC issued a highly-publicized Section 21(a) Report detailing the circumstances under which digital assets – such as “tokens” or “coins” – may be regarded as securities. In a recent speech, SEC Chair Jay Clayton touched on securities law issues surrounding ICOs – but as this blog from Duane Morris’ David Feldman notes, it was his off-script remarks that were the most interesting:

Chairman Clayton went a bit further today, going off his script to say that he has yet to see an ICO that doesn’t have “sufficient indicia” of being a securities offering. He also mentioned that the trading platforms could face SEC scrutiny and might have to either register as national securities exchanges or make clear they have an exemption from doing so.

Pro tip – If Jay Clayton hasn’t seen an ICO that didn’t involve a securities offering, you should expect the SEC to be skeptical of arguments that “this one’s different.”

ICOs: Disclose That I’m Getting Paid? But I’m a Celebrity!

I’ve reached the conclusion that the SEC is totally out of touch (said with “tongue in cheek”). If the folks who worked there watched TMZ like the rest of us, they’d know better than to suggest that our nation’s celebrities should have to comply with the law like ordinary people.

Unfortunately, based on this recent statement addressing unlawful celebrity promotional activities for ICOs, everybody at the SEC must be watching C-SPAN. Here’s an excerpt:

Any celebrity or other individual who promotes a virtual token or coin that is a security must disclose the nature, scope, and amount of compensation received in exchange for the promotion. A failure to disclose this information is a violation of the anti-touting provisions of the federal securities laws. Persons making these endorsements may also be liable for potential violations of the anti-fraud provisions of the federal securities laws, for participating in an unregistered offer and sale of securities, and for acting as unregistered brokers.

The reference to touting in the statement’s “parade of horribles” is interesting. Touting is prohibited by Section 17(b) of the Securities Act, but in recent years, it hasn’t featured prominently in the SEC’s enforcement efforts – that is, until last spring, when the Division of Enforcement conducted an anti-touting “sweep” targeting 27 firms and individuals. Of course, none of the defendants in those cases had their own television show, much less their own line of non-stick cookware. We’re posting memos about SEC enforcement actions in this area in our “ICOs” Practice Area.

ICOs: Most People Who’ve Heard of Coin Offerings Think They’re Illegal – and Plan to Invest

According to this LendEDU survey addressing public awareness of cryptocurrencies & initial coin offerings:

– 25% of Americans have heard of ICOs
– 21% of Americans believe that ICOs are illegal
– 15% of Americans intend to invest in ICOs

So, while roughly 85% of Americans who’ve heard of ICOs think they’re illegal, 60% of the members of that same group intend to invest in them. Now, I suppose some or all of that 15% could have come from the 75% of Americans whom the survey says have never heard of an ICO – but I’m not sure whether that’s better or worse…

Anyway, to me, this says 3 things:

– First, the SEC is going to have a heck of a time policing this stuff
– Second, the 60% deserve what they get
– Third, resistance is futile

Welcome to “DotCom II: The Tokening,” everybody! It’s a long way off, but we have just posted the flyer for this webcast: “The Latest on ICOs/Token Deals.”

– Posted by John Jenkins

My View: As the price of bitcoin skyrockets and traders continue to pile into these “coins”, I grow more and more wary. Large bubbles tend to attract fraudsters and euphoria that will proliferate the bubble even more until it pops. Many of the perpetrators are well-known celebrities, many of which frankly don’t know understand the risks, or better yet, understand the risks and are using them to steal from unknowing investors. Cryptocurrencies is an area we will continue to be highly skeptical toward.